Have you been told by a
medical professional, friends, family member or even a figure on the Internet
that you should be following a low-carb diet for Diabetes or weight-loss? This
is something I hear from clients quite frequently. With my experience in counseling
and also the research, I am here to tell you that it is perfectly okay to eat
carbohydrates if you have Diabetes or want to lose weight. Shocking, I know!
Below are the top 4 reasons I have for not following a super low-carb diet
based on the majority of things I hear from clients.
1.
Low-carb means no fruit!
One of the first things
people tend to do when cutting carbs is cutting the fruit out! Fruit is packed fiber,
vitamins, minerals and antioxidants; even those “deadly” bananas! I don’t know
how many people come to me with Diabetes saying they can’t eat fruit. Let me
just say that when I look at the food diaries of these patients, most are not
overeating the fruits. Aim for whole fruit over juices and eat the skin if
possible since that is where a lot of the nutrients and fiber lay. Just see
below at just some of the research touting the benefits of fruits and
vegetables!
---->“In Chinese patients with Type 2 diabetes, higher dietary
fruit intake was
associated with a lower burden of carotid atherosclerosis as reflected
by lower carotid intima-media thickness and prevalence of carotid plaque.”1
---->“Fruit
and vegetable intake may decrease oxidative stress and inflammation
in this group of patients. An increased intake of fruit and
vegetables can therefore be beneficial for patients with type 2 diabetes, since these patients are
documented to have raised oxidative stress and inflammation.”2
---->"Plant-based diets, especially when rich in high-quality plant
foods, are
associated with substantially lower risk of developing T2D."3
2. Food
quality is still an issue.
Something else fun that
happens when people cut the carbs is that they tend to still eat the same junk-food
(chips, breads, etc.), but in smaller amounts. Less carbs does not change food
quality. If you just decrease the unhealthy carbs but don’t add the healthier
ones, you are still not feeding your body right! Let’s say for example you
normally have a sandwich for lunch. You since cut back to ½ a sandwich;
however, now you are hungrier. So, you end up doing some more lunchmeat or
loading up on extra peanut butter. I’m not saying that it is okay to eat the
chips, white breads, cakes, and cookies. What I am saying is that whole grains,
beans, quinoa, etc are all great carbohydrates that can be incorporated into a
healthy meal plan. The reality is that most people are not consuming enough whole
grains (see research article below) and eating whole grains and beans are a
great way to help decrease disease risk!
----> “Including pulses in the diet is a healthy way to
meet dietary recommendations
and is associated with reduced risk of several chronic diseases.”4
---->“Average intakes of whole grains are far below
recommended levels across
all age-sex groups, and average intakes of refined grains are well
above recommended limits.”5
3. Low-carb
to carb-binge
A couple things tend
to happy with a low-carb diet. The first is that many tend to overload on the protein,
which most people are getting enough if not more than enough of their
recommended intake. Secondly, most people tend to crave the carbohydrates
so much that they binge on them in about a week or two and end up stopping
"yet another diet." Hey, I am not saying you won’t lose
weight eating low-carb, what I am saying is that this is
not typically a sustainable diet.
4. Most
low-carb diets don’t get enough fiber.
On the same topic as point
#4, less carbs usually means less fiber. As I said, most people sub in the protein
for less carbs. You know what most people are NOT getting enough of in their
diet? Fruits and vegetables! What do fruits and vegetables have in them besides
vitamins and minerals…FIBER! One of the most cut-out-veggies is the beans! Did
you know that a half-cup of chickpeas has about 5g of fiber and a half-cup of
kidney beans has 8g of fiber? Fiber is beneficial because it can help to decrease
cholesterol levels, improve GI function, and also decrease your risk for heart
disease. See the research below for more reasons to get in the fiber!
----> "High
fibre may be better than high protein for weight (fat) loss in
obesity.”6
----> “A high-fibre bean-rich diet was
as effective as a low carbohydrate diet for weight loss, although only the bean-rich diet lowered atherogenic lipids.”7
----> “Increasing fiber intake lowers
blood pressure and serum cholesterol
levels. Increased intake of soluble fiber improves glycemia and insulin
sensitivity in non-diabetic and diabetic individuals.”8
So, what should you do now? Start by tracking your food intake. Maybe, you are
eating too many refined carbohydrates (cookies, white breads, etc). Maybe, you
are also eating too much in one sitting (3 cups of pasta). Maybe, your meals
are unbalance (heavy in carbs or protein). Start by checking out your food log
and seeing where you can incorporate a better meal balance.
Aim for meals to
have lean proteins, fiber-filled carbohydrates (whole grains) or starches, and
some non-starchy veggies. An example of a balanced meal could be: tofu
(protein), broccoli (non-starchy veg), and a red potato (starchy carb). Another
example could be fish, sautéed spinach, and brown rice. Another example could
be quinoa (protein + starchy carb), mushrooms and tomatoes (both non-starchy).
A snack could be an apple and peanut butter or veggies and hummus. The options
are endless!
Bottom line here, instead of eliminating a food group and possibly
making yourself miserable aim for meal balance and portion control. If all else
fails, find a Dietitian to help you with meal planning since we are the experts
when it comes to nutrition :)
Additional Links
Resources
1. Chan H, Yiu K, Wong C, Li S, Tam S, Tse H. Increased dietary fruit intake was associated with lower burden of carotid atherosclerosis in Chinese patients with Type 2 diabetes mellitus. Diabetic Medicine [serial online]. January 2013;30(1):100-108. Available from: Academic Search Premier, Ipswich, MA. Accessed June 29, 2016.
2. Åsgård R, Rytter E, Basu S, Abramsson-Zetterberg L, Möller L, Vessby B. High intake of fruit and vegetables is related to low oxidative stress and inflammation in a group of patients with type 2 diabetes. Scandinavian Journal Of Food & Nutrition [serial online]. December 2007;51(4):149-158. Available from: Academic Search Premier, Ipswich, MA. Accessed June 29, 2016.
3. Satija A, Bhupathiraju S, Hu F, et al. Plant-Based Dietary Patterns and Incidence of Type 2 Diabetes in US Men and Women: Results from Three Prospective Cohort Studies. Plos Medicine [serial online]. June 14, 2016;13(6):1-18. Available from: Academic Search Premier, Ipswich, MA. Accessed June 29, 2016.
4. Mudryj A, Yu N, Aukema H. Nutritional and health benefits of pulses. Applied Physiology, Nutrition & Metabolism [serial online]. November 2014;39(11):1197-1204. Available from: Academic Search Premier, Ipswich, MA. Accessed June 29, 2016.
5. Dietary Guidelines for Americans 2015
6. Adam C, Gratz S, Ross A, et al. Effects of Dietary Fibre (Pectin) and/or Increased Protein (Casein or Pea) on Satiety, Body Weight, Adiposity and Caecal Fermentation in High Fat Diet-Induced Obese Rats. Plos ONE [serial online]. May 25, 2016;11(5):1-16. Available from: Academic Search Premier, Ipswich, MA. Accessed June 29, 2016.
7. Tonstad S, Malik N, Haddad E. A high-fibre bean-rich diet versus a low-carbohydrate diet for obesity. Journal Of Human Nutrition & Dietetics [serial online]. April 2, 2014;:109-116. Available from: Academic Search Premier, Ipswich, MA. Accessed June 29, 2016.