Cereal Vs. Ice Cream

This past week I had the privilege of leading a nutrition supermarket tour. When my tour group came to the cereal aisle, many of my participants had a very eye-opening experience about all of the sugar in "healthy cereal" products. In talking about carbohydrates and sugar, one woman had a very interesting comment, "With that much sugar, I could have just had my bowl of ice cream for a snack. I thought I was being healthier by having cereal."

After the tour, I was curious to see how cereal, a so called wholesome breakfast, really stacked up to a bowl of ice cream. Here begins my investigation:

Raisin Bran (w/o Milk)(1 cup): 
-Calories: 190    -Total Fat: 1g       -Sodium: 210mg    -Total Carbs: 46g
-Fiber: 7g    -Sugars: 18g    -Protein: 5g  
-Additional Vitamins and Minerals

Raisin Bran (with skim milk)(1 cup): 
-Calories: 230    -Total Fat: 1g       -Sodium: 275mg    -Total Carbs: 52g
-Fiber: 7g    -Sugars: 24g    -Protein: 9g

Special K (with skim milk)(3/4 cup):
-Calories: 160    -Total Fat: 1g       -Sodium: 205mg    -Total Carbs: 33g
-Fiber: 3g    -Sugars: 16g    -Protein: 6g
  
Choc Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream (1/2 cup):
-Calories: 160    -Total Fat: 9g      -Sodium: 65mg       -Total Carbs: 20g
-Fiber: 0g    -Sugars: 14g    -Protein: 2g
-Vitamin A and Vitamin C

Chocolate Ice Cream (1/2 cup):
-Calories: 150    -Total Fat: 7g       -Sodium: 45mg    -Total Carbs: 19g
-Fiber: 1g    -Sugars: 14g    -Protein: 2g
-Vitamin A and Vitamin C

So, we have similar calorie ranges, especially with the ice cream and Special K cereal. The ice creams have a higher fat content and lower protein content; however, they have less sugar, calories, and sodium. The cereals have more sodium, carbohydrates and sugars; however, they also have fiber, protein, vitamins, and minerals.

What does that leave us with? Well, the cereals are a good source of fiber and protein, at the expense of too much sugar and sodium intake. I'm not sure how many people really measure out their cereals in the morning anyway. Most of the time, cereal is just poured in the bowl and eaten. Unless you measure your cereal (kudos to you), you will be likely multiplying all of the nutritional information by 2.

In terms of which is a "healthier snack," I would go for what tastes better. In the end, they both have a high carb/sugar content, as opposed to healthier snacks (like veggies, nuts, seeds, or fresh fruit). I really suggest checking the sugar content of your favorite cereals. If you have never took notice of the nutrition label, you may be surprised at how much sugar you are consuming. While cereal does have extra vitamins, minerals, protein (mostly due to the milk added), and fiber, it is not a significant amount to make a difference if you are eating an overall healthy diet. Most cereals are "enriched" with vitamins and minerals anyway, so they aren't really a "natural" source to begin with. Depending on the cereal, and ice cream, you choose, you may even end up with more skewed results than I found.

Some final advice:
1. Always read the nutrition label! Look at the ingredient list too. Ingredients are listed by weight, in descending order.
2. If sugar is one of the first 4 ingredients, skip it!
3. Compare products. Check out all of the nutrients and see which is the best option.
4. Be mindful of portion sizes. Read the serving size and compare it to what you are normally eating.
5. If all else fails, have a little splurge and enjoy what you are eating!

http://www.turkeyhill.com/products/premium-ice-cream-flavors.aspx?pID=431

nutritiondata.self.com/facts/sweets/5547/2

How to Read a Nutrition Label

"Heart healthy!" "Low fat!" Confused on how to read a nutrition label? Well, you have come to the right place!

Why should you read a label anyway? For starters, it helps you determine the nutritional content of the product. It is also helpful for those with food allergies or intolerances. Reading the nutrition label helps you to see how the food fits into your overall diet.

One of the first things you want to look at when reading a nutrition label is the serving size. Many people consume over the amount suggested. You want to note the size of a single serving and how many servings are in the product. If you are doubling the serving size, you will need to double everything listed on the food label. For example, 20g of carbohydrates would then be 40g of carbohydrates.

As you look further down the label, you will see calories, calories from fat, total fat (includes saturated, trans, monounsaturated, and polyunsaturated fats), cholesterol, sodium, potassium, carbohydrates (includes fiber, sugars, and other carbohydrates), protein, vitamins, and minerals. To the right of these nutrients, you will see "% Daily Value." This is shown to see how the food fits into your overall diet. If a product says it has 5% of the daily value, it is considered a low source. 10% of the daily value is a good source and 20% or more of the daily value, it is considered a high source.

"Other carbohydrates" refers to the amount of starch in the product. Some products do not list "other carbohydrates." This number is found by subtracting both sugar and fiber from the total carbohydrates.

In general, you want to keep cholesterol, sodium, fat (trans and saturated), and added sugars low. Ingredients are listed in order from the greatest amount to the least. If sugar is one of the first 4 ingredients, toss the product aside and opt for something else. Sugars add calories with little to no nutritional value. You want to focus on foods that offer high amounts of mono and polyunsaturated fats, potassium, protein, fiber, vitamins, and minerals.

Labeling Terms and Tips
-"No" or "Zero" trans fat means that a product must have less than .5g per serving of trans fat.
-When a product says "lean" it means that total fat must be less than 10g and saturated fat must be less than 4.5g.
-A product that says "calorie free" has less than 5 calories per serving.
-"Low calorie" means that the product has less than 40 calories per serving.
-Fruit drink usually just has a lot of added sugar, little to no real fruit, and no fiber. Skip it and opt for a piece of fruit instead.
-"Sugar-free" or "fat-free" does not mean the product is low calorie or that has a high nutrient value. Most of the fat-free products just substitute sugar to make the product palatable.

Hopefully, this has helped you to see that reading a nutrition label is not as hard as it may seem. Just a few final tips: the fewer ingredients, the better and if you can't pronounce most of the ingredients, you might want to opt for something else.

Saturated Fat Vs. Trans Fat

Fats have certainly gotten a bad rap in the past few years. The new health craze has pushed for even more low-fat products.  But then again, some fats are good. This back and forth on fat sure makes it hard for consumers to know what to eat. Yes, you do need fat in your diet. It is essential for hormones, insulation, and protection of your organs from damage. The truth is that you do not need as much fat as you think. Also, the quality of the fat you eat is important. I am just going to focus on the two major harmful fats, Trans fat and Saturated fat. The healthy fats, Monounsaturated and Polyunsaturated, will be covered later. 

What Are Saturated Fats?
Saturated fats are mainly found in animal products and are typically solid at room temperature. Their chemical makeup consists of carbon atoms that are saturated with hydrogen atoms (hence the name "saturated" fat). The American Heart Association recommends limiting your intake of saturated fats to less than 7% of total calories. If you are consuming a 2,000 calorie per day diet, your intake of saturated fat would be less than 16 grams. 

Where Do You Find Saturated Fats in Foods?
Saturated fats occur naturally in many foods. Some examples include fatty beef, pork, and poultry with skin. Saturated fat is also found in butter, cheese, ice cream, and other dairy products made from whole or 2% milk. Many baked and fried foods contain high levels of saturated fats. 

Why Are Saturated Fats Harmful?

Saturated fat raises total blood cholesterol and LDL (bad) cholesterol levels. This increases your risk of heart disease and stroke. Studies have shown that saturated fat may also increase your risk of developing type 2 diabetes. 

What Are Trans Fats?
Trans fats are made during food processing through the partial hydrogenation of unsaturated fats. Hydrogenation basically means that hydrogen atoms are added to the carbon atoms. This process creates a product that is less likely to spoil, which increases the shelf-life of many foods. The American Heart Association recommends limiting your trans fat intake to less than 1% of your total calories. If you are consuming a 2,000 calorie per day diet, your intake of trans fat would be less than 2 grams. 

Where Do You Find Trans Fats?
Trans fat is found mainly in processed foods. Examples include cookies, crackers, cakes, some stick margarines, fried foods (donuts, French fries), chips, candy, and frozen dinners. When reading nutrition labels, look for the words "partially hydrogenated" in the ingredient list. Any oil that is partially hydrogenated is a trans fat. Be aware of the "0 Trans Fat" products. The FDA allows that phrase to be on any product with .5 grams of trans fat per serving. Since many people do not stick to serving sizes, they may be consuming more trans fat than they think. 

Why Are Trans Fats Harmful?
Trans fats raises your LDL (bad) cholesterol and lowers your HDL (good) cholesterol, a double whammy! Trans fats increase your risk of developing heart disease and stroke. Trans fat also increases blood triglyceride levels, which leads to hardening of the arteries (atherosclerosis). Studies have also shown that trans fat increases inflammation by damaging the cells lining your blood vessels. 

Tips for Lowering Saturated and Trans Fat

1. Eat a balanced diet rich in fruits and vegetables (no trans/saturated fat!).

2. Choose leaner cuts of meat and trim visible fat before cooking.

3. Remove the skin from chicken, turkey, and other poultry.

4. Drink low-fat or skim milk rather than whole or 2%. You will still be getting the same amount of calcium.

6. Decrease your intake of fast food. Many fast food restaurants still use partially hydrogenated oils for frying. 

7. Consume monounsaturated fat (olive oil) and polyunsaturated fat (soybean, sunflower oil).

Remember, not all fat is bad. You need fat in your diet! Also, be aware of the low-fat products. These so-called-healthy products simply swap saturated and trans fat for sugar. When in doubt, it is better to opt for a little fat over a lot of sugar.